Why Would a Guy Say NO to Friends With Benefits?

Did you finally muster up the courage to ask your hot guy friend to kick it up a notch, maybe get a little cozier, and perhaps add some extra ‘benefits’ to your friendship, only to be met with a disappointing ‘no’?

A sharp pain of rejection slices through you, leaving you feeling like a fish out of water, gasping for answers.

Are you not attractive enough for him? Or is he looking for something more serious with you, refusing to muddy the waters with casual intimacy?

Let me tell you, this is no playground bruise; it’s a kick right in the gut! You’re left there, thinking, dissecting, overthinking – staring into the abyss of questions, desperately seeking answers.

Okay, okay! Take a great big breath in… and sit back.

Trust me, his ‘no’ might not be about you at all. It might be him. Or the timing. Or the alignment of Venus with Mars on the third Tuesday of the month! The possibilities are endless!

Have you ever thought that maybe – just maybe – you were overthinking this whole thing?

So to clear things up, let’s take a look at the most common reason why a guy might say NO to FWB.

Don’t miss: 50+ Ways to Ask Someone to Be Friends with Benefits (FWB)

Why Would a Guy Say NO to Friends With Benefits?

1. He values your friendship

It isn’t uncommon for friendships to take a nosedive once the whole ‘benefits’ thing comes into play.

The waters get muddied, simple joys become complicated affairs, and before you know it, what was once a blooming friendship now resembles wilted roses.

2. Nasty history sneaking up

He’s not new to this ‘FWB’ thing. He’d ridden this roller coaster before, and boy was the ride bumpy!

Perhaps his last casual fling ended in an emotional whirlwind, or the fallout took a drastic toll on him.

Now, the idea of repeating history sends shivers down his spine no matter how attractive you are.

3. He’s got his heart set somewhere else

Alright, steel your heart for this one because it might sting just a tad! He could be reserving his romantic interests for someone else.

Now, this doesn’t mean you don’t rank high on the attractiveness scale; it just means that Mr. Cupid shot an arrow that didn’t have your name on it!

4. Casual isn’t his style

Believe it or not, some guys aren’t big fans of the ‘no strings attached’ arrangement.

For him, love isn’t about playing safe; it’s about putting your emotions on the line and going all in.

Your friend might be someone who likes the ‘relationship territory’ to be well-demarcated and solid.

5. Cultural or religious constraint

It might sound like something straight out of a 19th-century novel, but believe me, such men do exist.

Even in this era of technology and emancipation, some are profoundly influenced by their cultural or religious beliefs.

It’s merely a matter of personal principles and strongly held convictions. If he’s one of these men, the ‘no’ isn’t about you.

You are still the radiant, dazzling beauty that you always were.

Don’t miss: 50 Tinder and Bumble Dating Bio Examples for Casual Relationships

6. Potential drama

Let’s be real; casual relationships can sometimes pack a solid punch of drama. Emotions flow, misunderstandings flourish, and before you know it, you’re drowned in unnecessary complications and drama.

Could it be that he prefers the peace and tranquility of your current relationship over the stormy seas that a casual fling might stir up?

7. Fear of causing heartbreak

If he (being an amazing friend) thinks a casual relationship ends up setting false hopes and leaves you with a broken heart and shattered expectations, he might steer clear of that path.

Could he be thinking that by saying ‘no’ now he’s saving you from a world of hurt later?

8. Fear of being hurt himself

Emotions creep up on you when you least expect them to, don’t they? He might fear that he won’t be able to stick to the rules and could develop feelings.

Could it be that he doesn’t trust himself enough to keep feelings out of the equation in an FWB relationship with you?

9. You aren’t on his desire radar

This one might feel like a bit of a blow, but remember, everyone has their own definition of attractive.

It could simply be that while he enjoys hanging out with you, you don’t bag the top spot on his physical desire radar.

It doesn’t mean you aren’t all kinds of wonderful; you’re just not the kind of wonderful his heart is looking for.

10. Peer pressure

At times, a man would rather sacrifice his personal interests to maintain peace and harmony within his friends’ group.

As absurd as it may sound, he could have said no because he was too worried about the opinion inside his friend circle or was too afraid of stirring up any unnecessary friction or conflict.

Don’t miss: 50 Ways to Say “I’m Not Looking for Anything Serious”

11. He’s focusing on his growth

It could be that he’s in a phase where he’s more invested in self-improvement and personal growth and views any romantic distraction as a risk to his solo journey.

It might simply be about him wanting no distractions, even if the distraction in question is as tempting as an FWB arrangement with a pearl like you.

12. Already in the middle of a romantic turmoil

Sounds pretty cliché, right? But sometimes, life enjoys being a soap opera.

Your guy friend may be already tangled in a complicated romantic relationship.

And your proposition, although inviting, comes at the wrong time.

13. It’s a test

As confusing as it might seem, men can be equally mysterious when it comes to emotions.

He could have said ‘no’ just to see how you would react or to see if you really want to be FWBs or if it was just a spur-of-the-moment idea for you.

14. Fear of not being able to revert to being ‘just friends’

He might fear that once you cross the friendship line, there’s no going back.

Once you add benefits to the mix, going back to the plain ol’ friends bit seems unachievable. This fear of altering the status quo might be just enough to hold him back from saying yes.

15. He respects you too much

He holds too much respect for you to reduce you to an FWB. He believes such an arrangement might somehow belittle you or tinge your character with shades he wouldn’t want others to see or talk about.

16. Performance anxiety

Performance issues can dampen anyone’s spirit. Your friend might fear he won’t be able to perform well in bed, and the subsequent awkwardness could ruin your friendship.

17. Fear of judgment

Society has a notorious habit of raising eyebrows at non-traditional lifestyle choices.

He might fear potential societal backlash or judgment that could follow once people find out about your casual arrangement.

Read next: 50 Hook-Up Messages to Text Your Friend With Benefits